Two Balance Sheets
I'm responsible for two organizations whose balance sheets couldn't be more different.
The first is the organization I lead. A few years ago it sold the physical network it had built and operated, more than two thousand miles of fiber, and kept the mission that network served. What had been a set of hard assets became a managed portfolio. That transition happened because our board led it. They made the hard strategic calls, stayed engaged through a long and complicated process, and have backed me and our operations team through the implementation that followed. Much of what I know about governing a strong balance sheet, I've learned from watching them do it.
The second is a foundation I chair, and it takes on liabilities on purpose. Natural Streams Foundation assumes environmental obligations that companies have carried for decades, such as coal refuse piles, mine drainage, and land nobody can use, and reclaims them. Its balance sheet is defined less by what it owns than by what it has agreed to be responsible for.
The instinct is to call the first one healthy and the second one risky. Having sat with both, I've learned that each carries its own risk, and each asks something different of the board.
When everyone wants to be your friend
A strong balance sheet changes how the world treats you. The calls get returned faster. New partners appear. Everyone has a great idea, and everyone knows exactly how you should spend your fund.
Some of those ideas are good. Others are someone else's priorities looking for a funder. The real risk of a healthy balance sheet isn't losing money. It's losing focus, one reasonable-sounding opportunity at a time.
The discipline that matters most is remembering who you are. What is the mission? Who is the team that built the organization's strength? Which partners were with you before the balance sheet grew? A strong financial position is an asset only if it keeps serving the purpose that created it.
The board's job when you're strong
That discipline has a specific shape, and I've watched our board practice it. Once a strategy is decided, the board's job is to make sure it's followed, and that the operating team's decisions about using the funds trace back to it.
That isn't about second-guessing management. It's about giving management cover. A team that can point to a board-approved strategy has a clear, legitimate reason to say no to the next attractive idea. Without that, every new proposal becomes a fresh debate, and the organization slowly spreads itself across other people's agendas.
We've tried to treat the sale as the beginning of a set of decisions, not the end of one. Some of the capital went into research and education connectivity, through the creation and support of KeystoneREN, to sustain a core foundational part of the organization. Some went into people and new capabilities that let us take on digital inclusion and transformation initiatives in the communities we serve. Each of those choices has to be made again every year, against the strategy, not against whoever made the most compelling pitch that quarter.
When nobody wants to be your friend
The foundation lives on the other side of that equation. When you take on liabilities, people see you as the risk. Fewer partners come looking. The ones who do want to understand the exposure before they understand the mission. Your friends are limited.
So the team grinds. Every project gets built piece by piece: a grant here, a permit there, a partner who takes a chance after the third conversation. There's no cushion, and everyone knows it.
The board still owes that team direction and oversight. But the posture is different. A constrained organization can't afford a board that manages every decision, because the team's energy is already spoken for. The board's job is to set the direction clearly, and then let the people doing the work do it.
Clarity makes the grind possible
What makes that work is clarity about the money. At the foundation, every dollar has a job before it arrives. Grants are tied to specific projects. Trust funds are tied to specific obligations. Nobody has to ask what the money is for, because the obligation answers it.
That clarity is what lets a team grind without burning out. When people know exactly how the funds will be spent and why, they can put their effort into execution instead of justification. The clearer the purpose of every dollar, the easier the hard work becomes.
The same discipline from both directions
Running both has changed how I read a balance sheet. I used to look first at size and liquidity. Now I ask whether the organization knows who it is and what its capital is for, and whether the board is protecting that answer.
For the strong organization, protecting it means holding to strategy when everyone wants to be your friend. For the constrained organization, it means giving the team clear direction and the room to grind.
Either way, the question isn't how much you have. It's whether everyone, from the board to the people doing the work, knows what it's for.
Comments